Who loves a good creepy tablescape for Halloween? I love a good creepy eyeball decoration like these Dollar Store Halloween Eyeball Jars. This post contains affiliate links.

I have seen these Halloween eyeball ornaments every year at Dollar Tree. I just was there for a big stock up on health stuff like toothbrushes and hair stuff and saw the eyeball ornaments again.
What do you need to make Dollar Store Halloween Eyeball Jars?
You will need a few things:
- Eyeball ornaments (at Dollar Tree)
- Moss (Dollar Tree)
- Black rocks (Dollar Tree)
- Electronic Tea Lights (Dollar Tree)
- Glue dots (Dollar Tree)
- Mason jars (in plastic or glass) – Sometimes I can find these at the Dollar Tree, but I often find them at places like Dollar General and Family Dollar.
For added creepiness for the display also get:
- additional electronic tea lights
- plastic spiders/worms, etc.
- creepy cloth
- silver circle plate
How do you make Dollar Tree Halloween Eyeball Jars?
These jars are super easy to put together.
First, add about a 1-inch layer of black rocks to the bottom of the mason jar.
Then, add a 1-inch layer of moss on top of the rocks.

Next, place the eyeball ornament so that the top part of the ornament that sticks out goes down into the moss and is hidden. If you want to really secure it, you can add a dollop of hot glue to the top part of the ornament and push that into the moss to hold securely.
Add a glue dot to the center of the inside of the lid and stick the electronic tea light onto it. It’s easy to pull the light off and on the glue dot, so you can turn it on and off.

Screw the lid on and your eyeball jar is ready!
I like to make 3 jars with different colored eyes.
To decorate the mantle or a niche:
- Drape a gray creepy cloth down and add small skeletons, bugs, spiders, etc. around it.
- Add 3-5 electronic tea lights around the creepy cloth.
- Lay the metal mirrored plate down in the middle of all this and set the mason jars around the plate.
- Decorate the plate with some added moss, extra rocks, and additional bugs and creepy things.
Check out this video on how they look
More Halloween Ideas
- How to make Halloween Spider Web Pretzels
- DIY Dollar Store Halloween Monster Eye Votives
- How to make Dollar Tree DIY Pretty Pumpkins
If you love Halloween ideas, check out all the Halloween fun on The TipToe Fairy!

Dollar Store Halloween Eyeball Jars
Materials
- Eyeball ornaments
- Moss
- Black rocks
- Electronic Tea Lights
- Glue dots
- Mason jars
Instructions
Add about a 1-inch layer of black rocks to the bottom of the mason jar.
Add a 1-inch layer of moss on top of the rocks.
Place the eyeball ornament so that the top part of the ornament that sticks out goes down into the moss and is hidden. Add a dollop of hot glue to the top of the ornament to stick to the moss if desired.
Add a glue dot to the center of the inside of the lid and stick the electronic tea light onto it. It's easy to pull the light off and on the glue dot, so you can turn it on and off.
Screw the lid on and your eyeball jar is ready!
Come Join Us
Liked this article and want more? Follow along on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and YouTube!